Craig Groeschel: What Makes a Leader Irreplaceable in the World of AI | Carey Nieuwhof

How can we pray for you? Submit your prayer request today!

* indicates required

Artificial intelligence is reshaping how organizations work, how content is created and even how people relate to one another. On the Craig Groeschel Leadership Podcast, Craig Groeschel sits down with author and former pastor Carey Nieuwhof to explore what makes a leader irreplaceable in the world of AI. Their conversation is neither hype nor panic. Instead, it offers a balanced look at the real benefits of AI, the serious risks it poses to human flourishing, and the qualities that no machine can replace: authenticity, trust and genuine care for people.

Craig Groeschel and Carey Nieuwhof discuss leadership in the world of AI

Video Summary

Groeschel opens with a provocative question: what does Nieuwhof dislike about AI? Nieuwhof, who has researched the subject deeply for a book on AI and the future of the church, says his biggest concern is its potential impact on human flourishing, from mental health to finances and beyond. He recalls once teaching that social media was neutral and simply amplified what was already present, but says that after twenty-five years few people believe it has been a net positive for the next generation. In his view, AI may intensify those effects dramatically.

The two leaders then discuss how AI can help leaders serve people better, how to use it in content creation without losing critical thinking, the troubling rise of AI companionship and “therapy,” the need for transparent AI policies in organizations, and the danger of relying on AI for decision-making. They conclude that the right question is not which AI tool to use, but what impact AI will have on humanity, and that the most valuable leaders will remain deeply human and relational.

Key Takeaways

  • AI can greatly improve efficiency, data analysis and content editing, but it carries real risks to mental health and relationships.
  • Leaders should use AI to make themselves smarter, not lazier, and keep building their own thinking “muscles.”
  • Human relationships involve rupture and repair, something AI companionship cannot provide.
  • If you are not comfortable disclosing how you use AI, you are probably misusing it.
  • AI can summarize and analyze, but leaders should not hand over important decisions to it.
  • Human touch is becoming a luxury; organizations that keep people at the center will stand out.
  • The most important question is what impact AI will have on humanity.

Why AI Is Different from Previous Technology

Nieuwhof explains that one of the biggest surprises in his research was how little anyone fully understands about how today’s AI models behave. Traditional software is predictable: when something goes wrong, a programmer finds the bug and fixes it. According to Nieuwhof, advanced AI systems behave in ways even their creators admit they do not completely understand, and policymakers are struggling to keep up.

He compares the moment to the Y2K scare. Nothing catastrophic happened on January 1, 2000, but only because enormous resources were spent to prevent it. He hopes society can similarly slow down and prepare. Citing a prediction from a leading AI researcher that the AI revolution could be far bigger and faster than the industrial revolution, he notes that it took generations for laws to catch up with the abuses of the industrial age, including child labor and extreme working hours. Even the modern weekend, he points out, is only about a century old.

Groeschel shares his own perspective as a leader. So far, his organization has not seen AI reduce hiring; instead, people are becoming more efficient. Still, he acknowledges concerns about jobs, mental health, relational dependence on AI, privacy, deep fakes and misuse.

Using AI to Serve People Better

The conversation then turns to practical benefits. Nieuwhof describes how leaders can use AI to combine dashboards and reports far faster than manual analysis. In his years as a pastor, his church compiled reports on giving patterns at significant cost. The purpose was never to pressure people, he says, but to check in when someone’s giving changed. Those conversations often revealed that someone had lost a job, received a difficult diagnosis or was facing a family crisis, allowing the church to respond with care. AI can now surface that kind of information instantly.

On content creation, Nieuwhof explains that he wrote the first two drafts of his book entirely by himself before using AI to help clarify and streamline later drafts. He wanted to internalize the material rather than outsource his thinking. He tells a striking story about a university economics course where take-home exam scores were unusually high, apparently because of AI. When the final exam was moved to an in-person, pen-and-paper format, the class average dropped sharply. For Nieuwhof, the lesson is clear: if AI does the thinking, people learn very little.

Groeschel describes his own approach. He has organized thousands of his past talks into categories, and he uses AI to identify topics he has not yet addressed and then to interview him with questions one at a time. This approach mines his own ideas rather than replacing them. Interestingly, he finds it less helpful for sermons, which he describes as more spiritual and artistic than his leadership content. He urges younger leaders to build the skill of creating from scratch, because otherwise part of them will remain underdeveloped. Nieuwhof agrees, comparing it to paying someone else to work out at the gym for you.

The Risk of Replacing Human Relationships

One of the most sobering parts of the discussion concerns AI companionship. Nieuwhof cites research indicating that companionship and therapy have become leading uses of AI, and mentions other statistics about teenagers who prefer conversations with AI to conversations with people. Groeschel calls this horrifying, particularly from the standpoint of parents and leaders who care about the people they influence.

Nieuwhof explains that, much like social media, many AI products are designed to maximize engagement, and they tend to tell users what they want to hear. An AI never has a bad day, never needs anything and never walks away. But real relationships, he says, are a series of ruptures and repairs. Marriage, parenting and friendship all require working through conflict, and that process is part of what makes people grow. He also notes that a human counselor has limits on time, which can actually be healthy, while an AI will talk endlessly.

He refers to the long-running Harvard study of adult development, which has found that the quality of relationships in midlife is one of the strongest predictors of health and happiness later in life. In a world already facing a loneliness crisis, Nieuwhof warns that substituting AI for human connection could make things worse. He shares a story of a young mother who asked an AI for cooking advice, then realized she used to call her own mother for help, and chose to call her instead.

Transparency, Wisdom and Staying Human

Nieuwhof offers a memorable principle for organizations: if you are not comfortable disclosing how you use AI, you are probably misusing it. Customers, clients and congregations deserve to know how AI is being used in the work they receive. He also cautions leaders against relying on AI for decision-making. It can summarize and analyze, but wisdom and responsibility belong to people.

He contrasts a “race to the bottom,” where AI is used to cut costs and extract value, with a “race to the top,” where it is used to serve people better. He describes a friend who leads a large real estate company and insists that a real person answers the phone, giving the firm a major advantage over competitors who rely on automated systems. Echoing restaurateur Will Guidara, he argues that human touch is becoming a luxury good.

Finally, Nieuwhof urges leaders not to feel powerless. The right question, he says, is what impact AI will have on humanity, and especially on our children and grandchildren. Groeschel agrees that the more he uses technology, the hungrier he becomes for real human interaction. Both leaders connect this to the heart of their shared faith in Matthew 22:37-39: loving God with all one’s heart, soul and mind, and loving one’s neighbor as oneself. Anything that comes between people and their neighbors, Nieuwhof suggests, deserves careful thought.

For more leadership conversations from Craig Groeschel, read The Formula to Rewire Your Mind with Dr. Caroline Leaf and The Secret to Thriving Under Pressure with Dr. Wayne Chappelle.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes a leader irreplaceable in the age of AI?

According to Craig Groeschel and Carey Nieuwhof, the qualities AI cannot replace are authenticity, trust, wisdom in decision-making and genuine care for people. Leaders who stay relational and keep developing their own thinking will remain essential.

How does Craig Groeschel use AI in his work?

Groeschel organizes his past talks into categories and uses AI to identify topics he has not covered and to interview him with questions, helping him draw out and organize his own ideas rather than replacing them.

What are Carey Nieuwhof’s biggest concerns about AI?

Nieuwhof is most concerned about AI’s impact on human flourishing, including mental health, the rise of AI companionship, the loss of critical thinking and the possibility of replacing real human relationships.

Final Thoughts

This conversation offers leaders a thoughtful framework for navigating a fast-changing technological landscape. Craig Groeschel and Carey Nieuwhof do not dismiss AI; both use it and see real value in it. But they insist that leaders keep their eyes open, use AI to grow smarter rather than lazier, stay transparent, and never lose sight of people. In a world increasingly shaped by machines, the leaders who remain deeply human will be the ones who matter most.

Watch the Original Sermon

Write Your Prayer

* indicates required
Prayer Wall
Back to top button