Lysa TerKeurst: Their Chaos Doesn’t Have To Be Your Chaos | Therapy & Theology

How can we pray for you? Submit your prayer request today!

* indicates required

Some people seem to carry chaos wherever they go, and it can be surprisingly easy to get pulled into it. In this season finale of the Therapy & Theology podcast, Lysa TerKeurst, licensed counselor Jim Cress and theologian Dr. Joel Muddamalle discuss why their chaos doesn’t have to be your chaos. Their central point is simple but freeing: we cannot control other people, but Scripture calls us to exercise self-control, and that changes how we respond when chaos comes near.

Lysa TerKeurst on Therapy and Theology discussing chaos and self-control

Video Summary

TerKeurst opens the conversation by restating a theme from the whole season: we cannot control other people’s actions, reactions or narratives. But there is one kind of control the Bible clearly calls believers to practice, and that is self-control, listed among the fruit of the Spirit in Galatians 5:22–23. She describes people who seem to stir up drama, suggesting that sometimes outer chaos reflects inner chaos, and that such people may invite others to join in because the intensity feels familiar.

The hosts then walk through a list of common reactions, drawn from TerKeurst’s book on making peace with what we cannot control, that cause people not only to enter someone else’s chaos but to add to it. Each host candidly shares which ones they struggle with, and they close with practical strategies for growing in self-awareness and self-control.

Key Takeaways

  • We cannot control others, but we are called to self-control.
  • Chaos has a “gravitational pull” that can draw us in if we are not careful.
  • Personalizing, getting defensive, disconnecting, making assumptions, jumping to conclusions and reacting before thinking all add to chaos.
  • We do not have to correct every misstatement in the moment; a pause can prevent escalation.
  • “If you want calm, bring calm”: becoming a peacemaker rather than a peacekeeper.
  • Self-awareness must come before self-control.

The Anthill Lesson

TerKeurst tells a humorous story from childhood. Fascinated by an anthill in her yard, she kicked it, then decided to stand right in the middle of it. The ants, which turned out to be fire ants, swarmed up her legs and stung her. Looking back, she sees a vivid picture of choosing to participate in chaos she was never meant to enter. No matter how much someone hopes it will be different this time, ants will do what ants do.

Cress jokingly calls this a “self-whooping,” and Muddamalle adds an insightful observation: chaos seems to have its own gravitational pull, drawing people in until they find themselves living in it. The wise response, TerKeurst concludes, is to acknowledge that the anthill exists without jumping into it. Our job is not to fix the ants but to make wise choices about how we respond.

Six Ways We Add to the Chaos

Personalizing. Taking someone’s negative comment as a personal attack. TerKeurst admits she sometimes hears a neutral observation from her adult daughter as a verdict on her as a mother. Cress connects this to shame and to the story people tell themselves because of past wounds. One helpful reminder: just because someone lays something down does not mean we have to pick it up.

Getting defensive. Rushing to justify ourselves, sometimes with a sharp tone, which can actually make others’ accusations seem more legitimate. Cress shares an honest story of reacting with a frustrated facial expression during a scheduling conversation with his wife, then later apologizing and recognizing the deeper desire to reconnect beneath his reaction. TerKeurst adds a practical insight: she does not have to correct a false statement the instant it is spoken. She can let the person finish, breathe and then respond calmly.

Disconnecting. Using the silent treatment to avoid, detach or quietly punish. TerKeurst admits she sometimes swings from defensiveness to silence, which communicates without words. Cress notes that being quiet on the outside rarely means being calm on the inside, and he encourages listeners to move from being peacekeepers to peacemakers (Matthew 5:9). “If you want calm,” he says, “bring calm.”

Making assumptions. Projecting past experiences with other people onto the person in front of us instead of having the honest conversation that needs to happen.

Jumping to conclusions. Mentally racing to the worst-case scenario before hearing someone out. TerKeurst notes that people do sometimes have harmful patterns, but not every mistake is a pattern. Cress recommends mirroring: pausing and asking, “Is this what I hear you saying?” He also points out that “listen” and “silent” contain the same letters.

Reacting before thinking. Letting a rush of emotion dictate words and actions. Muddamalle describes the strange experience of almost watching himself overreact, and he encourages identifying personal triggers ahead of time so we can decide in advance how we will respond, much like the wisdom of James 1:19 to be swift to hear and slow to speak.

Self-Awareness Before Self-Control

In the closing portion, Cress explains that true self-control is built on self-awareness. Sometimes people react in ways that do not match their current age because an old, unhealed wound has been touched. Recognizing that, without shame, opens the door to healing and wiser responses. The hosts also emphasize co-regulation: trusted friends who help us calm down without condemning us. For more from TerKeurst and her team, read What Does It Mean To Be Relationally Healthy? and Why Your Relationship Keeps Struggling.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does “their chaos doesn’t have to be your chaos” mean?

It means that while we cannot control other people’s behavior, we can choose not to enter or add to their chaos by practicing self-control in how we respond.

What are common ways people add to chaos?

The hosts discuss personalizing, getting defensive, disconnecting, making assumptions, jumping to conclusions and reacting before thinking.

How can I avoid jumping to conclusions?

Jim Cress suggests pausing and mirroring back what you heard, such as asking, “Is this what I hear you saying?” before responding.

Final Thoughts

“Their Chaos Doesn’t Have To Be Your Chaos” combines humor, vulnerability and biblical wisdom. Lysa TerKeurst and her co-hosts remind listeners that self-control is not about suppressing emotions but about noticing them, pausing and choosing a response shaped by the Holy Spirit. The anthill will always be there; by God’s grace, we do not have to keep stepping into it.

Watch the Original Sermon

Write Your Prayer

* indicates required
Prayer Wall
Back to top button