Jack Hibbs: A Warning To The “Christian”
In A Warning To The “Christian”, Pastor Jack Hibbs asks a searching question: what does it really mean to be a Christian? Hibbs observes that we live in a “hyphenated” culture where believers often describe themselves by denominations, political leanings, ethnic backgrounds or lifestyles. Drawing on 1 Corinthians 1, Galatians 3 and 2 Corinthians 5, he argues that a believer’s primary identity is simply “in Christ,” and that adding labels can divide the church or even excuse ongoing sin.

Video Summary
Hibbs begins with a story from American history. As the colonies moved toward independence, Patrick Henry famously declared that he was no longer a Virginian, but an American. Regional labels gave way to a shared identity. Hibbs suggests that Christians need a similar shift.
He lists common labels believers use: Baptist Christian, Methodist Christian, non-denominational, progressive, liberal, conservative, evangelical and more. He then reads Paul’s rebuke of division in Corinth and his declaration in Galatians that believers are all one in Christ Jesus. Hibbs explores how ethnic and cultural labels can separate the body of Christ, and how identifying with ongoing patterns of sin is incompatible with the new life Christ gives. He closes by pointing to the reality that anyone in Christ is a new creation.
Key Takeaways
- Hibbs believes Christians often define themselves by labels more than by Christ.
- Paul rebuked the Corinthians for dividing over leaders and labels.
- In Christ, earthly distinctions do not determine spiritual identity.
- Ethnic and cultural backgrounds are real, but they should not divide the church.
- Hibbs distinguishes between being tempted and identifying with a sinful practice.
- The gospel makes believers new creations whose identity is found in Christ.
Patrick Henry and the End of the Hyphen
Hibbs describes Patrick Henry as one of the great orators of the American founding era, whose voice could stop a crowd. At a time when the thirteen colonies functioned almost like separate countries, Henry declared, “I am not a Virginian, but an American.” Hibbs uses this as an illustration: when a greater identity takes hold, lesser labels lose their power to divide.
“Is Christ Divided?”
Hibbs reads 1 Corinthians 1:10-17, where Paul pleads with believers to speak the same thing and be perfectly joined together in the same mind and judgment. Some in Corinth were saying, “I am of Paul,” “I am of Apollos,” “I am of Cephas,” or “I am of Christ.” Paul responded, “Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you?” Hibbs sees these factions as an early form of the “hyphenated” Christianity he is warning about.
He then turns to Galatians 3:26-29: “There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus.” In Christ, Hibbs explains, earthly distinctions no longer define a believer’s standing before God.
No Ethnic or Regional Divisions in the Body
Hibbs notes that the New Testament never records believers introducing themselves as “Galatian Christians” or “Macedonian Christians.” Their old identities, he says, had been swept away by the blood of Christ. He clarifies that it is perfectly fine to mention where you are from, but not to make that a dividing line in the church. He shares that he is part Portuguese, yet he does not call himself a “Portuguese Christian.”
He also expresses a desire to see congregations that reflect people of many backgrounds worshiping together. While communities may naturally be shaped by their surroundings, he insists that every person who walks into a church is equally precious to God, regardless of skin color. This echoes Revelation 7:9, which pictures a multitude from every nation, tribe and tongue worshiping before the throne.
Temptation Versus Identity
Hibbs then addresses a more sensitive point. He asks whether a person can attach a sinful practice to their Christian identity, using examples such as theft, drug use, alcoholism, pornography and same-sex relationships. He draws a clear distinction between being tempted, which every believer experiences, and adopting a sinful practice as a defining identity. In his view, Christians may struggle with many temptations, but they are called not to embrace sin as who they are.
He also cautions against equating unchosen characteristics, such as ethnicity, with behavioral choices. These are Hibbs’s convictions, and readers from different backgrounds will engage them in different ways, but his underlying point is that Christ calls every believer to a new identity rather than a blended one. For a related message, see A Warning To The Church Of 2026.
The Right Recipe
With humor, Hibbs describes making pancakes without following the order of the recipe. He had all the right ingredients, but the result was lumpy and inedible. In the same way, he says, trying to weld the old life to the new life in Christ does not work; it is like mixing iron and clay. God’s “recipe” is that believers die to the old self and are made new in Christ. As Paul writes in 2 Corinthians 5:17, “If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; old things have passed away; behold, all things have become new.” For more from Hibbs, see Knowing The Gospel Won’t Save These People.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Jack Hibbs mean by a “hyphenated Christian”?
He means identifying primarily by a label, such as a denomination, political view, ethnicity or lifestyle, rather than by one’s identity in Christ.
Is it wrong to belong to a denomination?
Hibbs’s concern is not affiliation itself but allowing labels to divide believers or replace their primary identity in Christ.
What is the difference between temptation and identity in this message?
Hibbs teaches that all believers face temptation, but they are called not to embrace a sinful practice as a defining part of who they are.
Final Thoughts
A Warning To The “Christian” challenges believers to examine what truly defines them. Jack Hibbs calls the church to lay down divisive labels and embrace the unity and transformation found in Christ. Whatever one’s background or struggle, the invitation of the gospel is the same: to become a new creation whose identity rests in Jesus alone.