Jack Hibbs: I Figured Out Why Lindsay Clancy Killed Her Kids
The tragic case of Lindsay Clancy has sparked countless debates and podcasts. In this message, Pastor Jack Hibbs steps back from the online arguments to ask a bigger question: why are cases of parents killing their own children increasing? His answer is rooted in history and Scripture—he argues that as a culture moves away from the Judeo-Christian worldview, the value of human life erodes and spiritual darkness grows.

Note: This article discusses the deaths of children. If you or someone you know is struggling after childbirth, postpartum depression and psychosis are real medical conditions—please reach out to a doctor, your local emergency services, or a postpartum support line right away.
Video Summary: Why Lindsay Clancy Killed Her Kids
Pastor Jack is clear that he is not cutting anyone slack, nor arguing from emotion. He acknowledges that postpartum depression is real and that mothers need to be loved, cared for and protected during that time. But he asks why child killings appear to be rising in the West, and he argues that the root issue is ultimately spiritual. He traces how Christianity historically ended child sacrifice and infanticide, critiques the culture’s celebration of abortion, and calls the church to be salt and light.
Key Takeaways
- Child sacrifice has existed throughout history, but it declined wherever the Bible’s influence spread.
- Postpartum depression is real—mothers need love, care and protection, and families must support them.
- Pastor Jack sees the rise in filicide as spiritual, tied to the decline of Christian influence.
- Christianity changed Rome: under Christian influence, infanticide and gladiatorial games were ended.
- A culture that celebrates abortion, he argues, devalues children at every stage.
- America has become post-Christian, and the church must not stay silent.
- Jesus warned against harming children (Matthew 18:6)—God sees and will judge justly.
An Old Evil, a New Rise
Pastor Jack notes that parents sacrificing children is not new—it appears throughout world history. But in the West, child sacrifice has long been seen as pagan and abhorrent. Why? Because wherever Judaism and Christianity have gone, the practice has declined. When the gospel reached places like Papua New Guinea, he says, child sacrifice ended. Light pushed back the darkness.
He reads a news headline about a newborn found in a dumpster in Los Angeles and cites FBI figures indicating roughly 450 to 500 cases a year in which children are killed by a parent—a number he says is rising. He also describes disturbing cases in which mothers later said they did not remember harming their child, which he believes points to something beyond purely physical explanations.
Postpartum Depression Is Real
Pastor Jack is careful not to dismiss mental health. “I’m not discrediting postpartum depression. It’s a real deal,” he says. Hormonal and chemical changes after childbirth can be devastating. Women going through this need to be loved, nurtured and, in some cases, protected from themselves. That, he says, is part of what it means to be a husband, a family and a church.
Pastor Jack’s Answer: A Spiritual Battle
Still, he argues that if child killing rises as Judeo-Christian influence falls, the deeper cause must be spiritual. “Why is it a fact that wherever Christianity is proclaimed and embraced, human life is honored and protected?” he asks. Remove the debates over parties and labels, he says, and you are left with God and Satan. Jesus said, “The thief does not come except to steal, and to kill, and to destroy. I have come that they may have life, and that they may have it more abundantly” (John 10:10).
How Christianity Changed the Roman Empire
Pastor Jack points to Rome, where for centuries it was legal to abandon or kill infants considered “defective.” Who defined defective? A birthmark? A deformed foot? He then recounts the story of Telemachus, a Christian who, according to tradition, protested the gladiatorial games and was killed for it—an act that helped bring the games to an end. In the fourth century, as Christianity spread through the empire, Roman law outlawed infanticide. Christianity, not politics, restored the value of the child.
A Culture That Celebrates Death
Pastor Jack strongly criticizes laws expanding abortion access and the public celebrations that sometimes accompany them. He argues that a culture that applauds ending life before birth should not be surprised when children are devalued after birth. “Everyone who is for abortion,” he observes, “has already been born.” While miscarriage is a heartbreaking reality in a fallen world, he says, abortion is a human choice.
A Post-Christian Nation
In one of the most pointed parts of the message, Pastor Jack says America, in its 250th year, is no longer the nation its founders knew. The Constitution, the Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights, he argues, have died “in the hearts and minds” of many. He believes nations bear the consequences of their collective sins—Daniel, Joseph and Jeremiah were carried away not for their own sins, but for their nation’s. He also criticizes so-called revivals that baptize thousands without ever calling people to repentance.
God Sees, and Justice Is Coming
Pastor Jack finds comfort in the fact that God sees every act of cruelty against a child and never forgets. Jesus said, “Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in Me to sin, it would be better for him if a millstone were hung around his neck, and he were drowned in the depth of the sea” (Matthew 18:6). That, he says, is justice and righteousness—and it is coming.
What Should the Church Do?
- Love and protect mothers, especially those struggling after childbirth.
- Value every human life—from conception to natural death (Psalm 139:13-16).
- Be salt and light; don’t fear social media more than God (Matthew 5:13-16).
- Preach repentance along with the good news.
- Pray for the nation: “Blessed is the nation whose God is the Lord” (Psalm 33:12).
For more from Pastor Jack, read Are We Seeing God’s Prophetic Will Being Fulfilled? and I Was Warned Not To Interview This Man.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Jack Hibbs deny postpartum depression?
No. He explicitly says postpartum depression is real and that mothers need love, care and protection. He argues, however, that the overall rise in child killings has a deeper spiritual dimension.
How did Christianity affect infanticide in history?
As Christianity spread in the Roman Empire, the practice of killing or abandoning infants was condemned and eventually outlawed in the fourth century, and the gladiatorial games were later abolished.
What does the Bible say about harming children?
Jesus warned severely against harming children (Matthew 18:6), and Scripture affirms that every child is fearfully and wonderfully made (Psalm 139:14).
Final Thoughts
Behind every headline is a real tragedy, and behind the cultural trends Pastor Jack sees a spiritual battle. The answer is not merely political, but the light of Christ that values every life. Love the hurting, protect the vulnerable, and pray that God would have mercy on our nation.
